The US already has student debt forgiveness, but almost no one gets it.



The Biden administration indicated that the president would ask Congress to forgive $ 10,000 student debt to all borrowers – a step below leaders of his own party called forHouse as well as Senate Democrats called on President Biden “broadly” forgive up to $ 50,000 in federal debt by order.

Public dialogue has rekindled interest in student debt cancellation, but many may not realize that the United States already has student debt cancellation programs – public recognition that student debt cancellation can be fair and necessary – just very few people actually benefit from these programs. …

For example, while the Obama administration approved the forgiveness of student loans for borrowers who were deemed cheated by commercial schools, the Trump administration delayed forgivenessdoing it almost impossible to qualify… This is as long as last week when the Biden administration announced that some 72,000 borrowers who had been defrauded by their schools would be forgiven for up to $ 1 billion in student loans.

For decades, politicians (including Biden) have proposed adjusting existing student debt write-off programs. But support for wider student debt forgiveness Ironically, many experts emphasize that any new policy must learn from the mistakes of the past.

Income-Based Forgiveness

Since 1995The US has offered income-adjusted repayment options that allow borrowers on federal student loans to pay interest (usually 10%) from their discretionary income on loans each month with the promise of repayment of the remaining balances in 20 or 25 years, depending on policy

Although the program aimed to provide borrowers with an affordable way to pay off their debts, some low-income borrowers owed more over time because their mandatory payments were insufficient to cover rising interest rates.

National Center for Consumer Law It is estimated that while nearly two million student loan borrowers have repaid over 20 years, only 32 borrowers have ever been eligible for loan cancellation under the federal government’s revenue-driven repayment program.

Persis Yu, director of NCLC’s student loan facilitation project, says the program did not result in student loan forgiveness for more borrowers due to lack of awareness of the program and the “Byzantine” hurdles that borrowers must overcome to qualify. …

“There are many minefields that borrowers must overcome to get into income-driven repayment plans and stay in income-driven repayment plans,” Yu says, explaining that borrowers must re-register with the IDR plan every year. in order to qualify. “And we also know that there were significant obstacles in the way of borrowers with service companies, forcing borrowers to refuse to delay or abstain or not inform them about the options available.”

Of the 45 million Americans with student loan arrears, 8 million are currently participating in the federal IDR plan. Yu argues that the current system does not provide incentives for service companies to help borrowers pay off debt.

“Payments on income are administratively burdensome for both borrowers and maintenance staff,” she says. “Advising a borrower is more work and for some service providers it isn’t worth it. One of the things we’ve seen is that some service centers have a limit on the amount of time the call representative had to speak. borrower. Well, you cannot give adequate advice to someone on an income payment plan if you only have a certain number of seconds or minutes to do so. “

The small number of people who are actually paid student debt payments “is very similar to what happened with the public service loan forgiveness program,” says Yu.

Forgiveness for civil service

The second current policy to forgive federal student debt is Public Service Loan Forgiveness (PSLF) program.

The PSLF was created under the College Cost Reduction and Access Act 2007, which allows directly federal loan borrowers who make 120 eligible monthly payments while working full time for a suitable employer so that the rest of their balance is forgiven. Eligible employers include any federal, state, local or tribal government and non-profit organization.

But the program also did not help many borrowers.

In 2018The Ministry of Education released data showing that 29,000 borrowers applied for forgiveness for their student loans under the PSLF, but only 96 were forgiven. This means that more than 99% of borrowers who applied for help were refused.

In response, Congress authorized expansion of the program… However, in 2019 Report of the Accounts Chamber of the Government found that approximately 99% of requests for loan forgiveness under this recently expanded program were rejected. According to the report, the Department of Education processed about 54,000 requests for forgiveness, approved only 661, and spent only $ 27 million of the $ 700 million allocated by Congress for the expanded program.

Courtesy of the Government Accounts Chamber

BUT recent poll Of the 664 government employees who received federal student loans from AIG Retirement Services found that while 90% of government employees with college debt are aware of the PSLF program and 84% find the program attractive, 70% “demonstrate only minimal understanding” of the program’s rules and requirements. Simply 30% of those surveyed showed a general understanding of how to qualify.

“Many of the people we interviewed knew about the PSLF program but didn’t know how to navigate,” says Rob Scheinerman, CEO of AIG Retirement Services. “As student debt forgiveness is becoming an important topic of public policy discussion, it gives us a platform for people to know that it exists right now.”

What can you find out

But how new apprentice Progress of Debt Forgiveness Proposalspeople like Yu and Ashley Harrington, federal director of advocacy and senior advisor to the Center for Responsible Lending, say the current student debt cancellation policy could provide an even more important lesson on how to effectively provide significant student debt relief: simplicity is key. to success.

“One of the takeaways of these student loan forgiveness programs is that trying to figure out who deserves to be canceled and who doesn’t is actually very difficult,” says Yu. you really get help for the people who need it is to give it to everyone.It’s the fairest way to make sure you don’t waste government resources.Cut up your student loan portfolio and spend money to hide money from other people instead of just pass them on to those who need them. “

“What we’ve learned from income-based payments, government service loan forgiveness, these programs that are supposed to help student borrowers, is how difficult it is,” Harrington says. “The fact that only 32 borrowers were forgiven by the IBR, the fact that so few borrowers were forgiven by the PSLF (even when Congress took steps to correct some of the service errors) only underscores why we need to make large-scale cancellations as easy as possible to gain access whenever possible and do not erect barriers. “

“Because we know what happens when we put up these barriers.”

Do not miss:


Source link