Tax implications of flash cryptocurrency loans – technology



Canada: Tax implications of flash cryptocurrency loans

To print this article, you only need to register or log in to

Introduction: Taxation and the Emerging World of Cryptocurrency Trading

Explosive growth cryptocurrency trading The past few years have proven to be a major headache for the Canadian tax system in terms of tax compliance. The Revenue Agency of Canada (CRA), Canada’s primary tax regulator, has often struggled to keep up with the pace of economic innovation that has originated in the decentralized and unregulated cryptocurrency market. “Fast Loans” is one such recent innovation that will surely pose problems for both the Canadian Revenue Service and the Canadian courts. If you have or are involved in cryptocurrency trading, in particular using urgent loans, you should consult one of our experts. Canadian Cryptocurrency Tax Lawyers to navigate the tax aspects of your business, especially in light of Canada’s rapidly evolving views on cryptocurrency trading.

What is Flash Cryptocurrency Loan?

Before diving into short-term loans, it would be helpful to analyze the closest analog available within our modern regulated financial system. A day loan or “day loan” is a common lending instrument available through banks and institutions. With a day loan, the principal amount of the loan is disbursed and repaid with interest accrued within one day. A day loan is a popular tool for organizing sequential transactions in one day, as it provides easy access to increased capital, minimizes the cost of interest and any problems that may be associated with a loan with a longer maturity, and provides complete documentation at all times. transfers of funds under transactions.

A term loan is a form of unsecured loan. Basically, a term loan is similar to a day loan in the sense that it is designed to enable the borrower to facilitate quick transactions without long-term commitments. However, unlike a day loan, the actual repayment of the loan and the repayment of the loan occur simultaneously. Many cryptocurrencies operate through a public ledger system that requires cryptocurrency transactions to be verified and recorded in public records. Once verified, transactions are placed in the ledger as blocks, which allows multiple transactions to be executed simultaneously.

As a consequence of the ledger system, a contract that includes both the advance of the cryptocurrency and the redemption of the cryptocurrency can be created and executed at the same time. The decentralized nature of cryptocurrency exchanges has made flash loans a popular tool for many traders who discover price differences between currencies on exchanges. A term loan allows the trader to use a significant amount of capital with minimal risk to engage in arbitrage or asset swaps when the opportunity arises.

Importance of Canadian tax regulations for term loans

Section 18 (1) (b) of the Income Tax Act (“”) prohibits deduction from taxpayer’s income from business or from the use of property in respect of “cost, loss or replacement of capital” or “payment of capital.” Section 20 (1) (c) Tax Law, alternatively, allows for a deduction from the taxpayer’s income from business or property in respect of payments of interest on a loan. deducted from that taxpayer’s income The tax savings can be significant for the taxpayer depending on the amount of interest paid on the loan in question.

However, according to these rules, instant borrowing is a serious problem. Because of the way the accounting system works, the quick loan lender will never actually give up the principal of the loan. Generally speaking, Canadian courts have concluded that daily interest is a fundamental element in classifying a payment, amount or right under a contract as interest payments. Federal Court of Appeal in Perini Estate vs. Minister of State Revenue, [1982] CTC 74 (FCA) establishes three requirements, the fulfillment of which will result in the payment of an amount in the form of interest for tax purposes (emphasis added):

  1. The amount was compensation for the borrower’s use of the money;
  2. The amount was determined daily;
  3. The amount related to the outstanding principal.

Simultaneous repayment and repayment of a term loan completely contradicts these principles. The repayment to the lender is calculated in direct proportion to the loan amount and does not actually accumulate over time at any given moment. What can be considered as interest on a term loan is simply a condition that must be met for the contract to be fulfilled. The contract could not be awarded if the amounts due were not actually paid at the same time as the provision of the term loan.

The fact that a term loan is contrary to the basic principles of the interest rate is worrying, but may not be fatal for classifying a portion of the payment as interest. Processing interests by Canadian courts in case-law such as Perini as well as
Miller vs. Queen, [1985] 2 CTC 139 (FCTD) were not entirely dependent on daily accruals as a factor for classifying the amount as interest. Conclusion of the Supreme Court of Canada in Queen vs. Melford Developments Inc., [1982] CTC 330 (SCC) confirms the view that interest cannot be classified according to a restrictive test that focuses on daily accrual as the main component. Consequently, it is still within the likelihood that the courts will revise and re-evaluate the definition of interest to include instant repayment. Canadian courts have historically condemned the consideration of an amount as a percentage simply because it was so designated, and instead chose to analyze the nature of the transaction. Only time will tell how the courts will treat the repayment of a term loan in relation to the classification of any amount as interest.

Tax advice: quick loan transactions may be taxed

Regardless of whether interest is deducted on instant loans, the decision to use flash credit to trade cryptocurrency itself may incur tax liabilities. Cryptocurrency trading in Canada is generally subject to the same rules as trading any other commodity. Trade in goods in Canada usually gives rise to tax liabilities after the disposal of the property. The decision to use flash credit to take advantage of the market imbalance can qualify as an order when cryptocurrency changes hands quickly. This is likely even if you are simply exchanging one cryptocurrency for another and are not converting your cryptocurrency to a fiat currency such as Canadian dollars.

Therefore, it is imperative that you accurately track what you are trading and the value of that cryptocurrency both upon receipt and upon disposal. With significant regulatory amendments that took effect in Canada on June 1, 2021, reporting obligations for cryptocurrency exchanges are more onerous than ever. All cryptocurrency exchanges in Canada are now required to register with the Financial Transaction Analysis and Reporting Center of Canada (FinTRAC) and record, among other things, information on the parties involved in a transaction of more than CAD 10,000. It is possible that by participating in quick loan deals, you will fall into the trap of these rules. With an increased level of control and oversight of cryptocurrency traders, it is more important than ever that you keep appropriate records of your trades and accurately report earnings. You should contact expert Canadian tax lawyer if you are worried about how to classify your income from cryptocurrency transactions, or if you have been involved in instant credit trading and have not properly filed your income in tax returns before.

The content of this article is intended to provide general guidance on the subject. You should seek professional advice regarding your specific circumstances.

POPULAR ARTICLES ON: Technology from Canada

Cybersecurity Laws and Regulations 2021

McMillan LLP

Canada covers general issues in cybersecurity laws and regulations, including cybercrime, applicable laws, attack prevention, specific sectors, corporate governance, litigation, insurance, and investigative and police powers.

AI and Dispute Resolution: Friends of Enemies?

McCarthy Tétrault LLP

On May 13, 2021, the London Dispute Week (“LIDW21”) conference hosted an Influencers Panel to discuss the intersection of artificial intelligence (“AI”) and dispute resolution.


Source link