Has student loan abolition spurred the economy even without widespread student loan forgiveness?

Student Loan Cancellation: Financial Incentive

There are several reasons for canceling a student loan. Large-scale student loan cancellations will help millions of student loan borrowers get out of debt faster so they can buy a house, start a family, save money for retirement, and break out of the bondage of high-interest debt. One of the main arguments for widespread student loan abolition is that student loan forgiveness is stimulating the economy. The argument goes something like this: if student loan borrowers don’t have a student loan, they might have more money to spend in other sectors of the economy. In addition, when 45 million Americans collectively have $ 1.7 trillion in student loan debt, economists argue that this negatively affects the economy.

Here’s a counterargument: Since March 2020, a student loan exemption has been granted. Until January 31, 2022, almost 90% of student loan borrowers did not have to pay student loans due to the Student Loan Loan Exemption under the Cares Act ($ 2.2 Trillion Incentive Package) for 22 months. Although this exemption from the student loan did not result in outright cancellation of the student loan, non-payment of the student loan has an economic effect similar to the cancellation of the student loan, even if it is temporary. Without a student loan requirement, student loan borrowers can use their money for other purposes, such as saving for retirement, paying off other debt, or starting a business. The Covid-19 pandemic is taking its toll on this period, although unemployment today is relatively low by historical standards.

Canceling a $ 50,000 student loan does not mean that student loan borrowers will receive $ 50,000.

The US Department of Education estimates that if a student loan of up to $ 50,000 is canceled, all of its student loans will be repaid to 36 million student loan borrowers. However, canceling a $ 50,000 student loan does not mean that the student loan borrower will receive the same amount of money to spend in the economy. Instead, the student loan borrower saves his monthly student loan payment. This can amount to less than $ 400 of additional funds each month, rather than tens of thousands of dollars. Since student loan borrowers no longer pay off their student loans, the expected economic effect of a large-scale write-off of student loans may already be reflected in the current level of economic activity… However, canceling a student loan will have a longer lasting economic impact, as the temporary student loan exemption is only a two-year window (whereas canceling a student loan could provide a 10-year economic incentive).

How Student Loan Cancellation Compares To Incentive Checks

Congress is prioritizing incentive reviews over student loan cancellations. Why? Economists estimate that large-scale student loan cancellations will only have economic consequences. $ 0.08 to $ 0.23 for every dollar of student loan forgiveness… In comparison, incentive checks fetch $ 0.60 for every dollar. The researchers argued that with limited federal funds available for economic stimulus from Congress, there are more effective economic measures – such as stimulus checks or heightened unemployment insurance – that can stimulate the economy more than widespread student loan cancellations. This alone does not mean that abolishing the student loan does not stimulate the economy; forgiving student loans will stimulate the economy. However, the researchers say that the relative stimulating effect large-scale student loan cancellation will be less than other economic incentives… The potential for future economic incentives can be measured today – before there is a large-scale student loan cancellation – because 22 months of student loan benefits could mimic the economic impact.

If you have student loans, make sure you manage your student loan payments now. Don’t wait until February. Here are some popular ways to pay off student loans and save money:

Student Loans: Related Materials

Here’s What Biden Student Loan Exemption Means For Your Student Loans

The infrastructure package includes a car miles tax program.

Student Loan Cancellation Spotlight on Capitol Hill Today

Canceling a student loan may help more borrowers, but that doesn’t mean that Biden will cancel all student loans.